Effort to provide Indigenous Governments permanent place at U.N. stalls

August 4, 2017 | The United Nations will delay any substantive action on their work to enable the participation of indigenous peoples’ representatives and institutions at the UN. After years of discussions among indigenous peoples and member states, and several weeks of states-only negotiations this summer, member states were not able to reach consensus on the details of how to create a new status or category for indigenous governments.

The General Assembly is now expected to adopt a resolution in September, 2017, that will establish a new, multi-year schedule of consultations and discussions about the details of these important questions.

“It is disappointing that the UN was not able to follow through on its commitments to enhance the ability of indigenous peoples’ governments and representative institutions to contribute to the UN’s work,” said Karla General, Indian Law Resource Center attorney. “Despite being some of the first governments of the world, indigenous peoples’ governance institutions are among the last to be afforded access to the UN. Yet, we are encouraged to see there will be a clear calendar for continued discussions of this matter in the coming years. There is much work to be done to secure a good outcome, and we remain committed to working with indigenous peoples around the world and with all member states to do so.” 

Indigenous peoples and member states have been consulting and working on developing common language on participation since the World Conference on Indigenous Peoples in 2014. In May, an initial first draft of the resolution, based on input from indigenous peoples, member states, and UN agencies, was submitted for consideration by member states. After many negotiations and multiple revisions, states reached an impasse on the question of a no-objection procedure, a mechanism that would allow a member state to secretly exclude an applicant from being credentialed to participate at the UN without providing any reasons. Because this process is secret, the no-objection procedure would effectively shield the objecting member state from political retribution and public scrutiny.

Because of the lack of consensus, the draft resolution simply commits the General Assembly to continue consideration of the issue in the coming years, and delays any actual decision on participation until the 75th Session of the General Assembly, which begins September 2020 and ends September 2021. In the interim, the Secretary-General is tasked with coordinating regional consultations with indigenous peoples and producing a report with recommendations informed by the results of the regional consultations and the 2017 consultations. In addition, the draft resolution asks the President of the General Assembly to conduct three interactive hearings among member states and indigenous peoples during the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues’ annual sessions in 2018-2020. The results of the consultations, the Secretary-General’s report, and the hearings are all intended to contribute to future consideration of the issue.

RESOURCES

"Enhancing the Participation of indigenous Peoples' Representative and Institutions in Meetings of Relevant United Nations Bodies on Issues Affecting Them" Draft Resolution | August 15, 2017

Participation at the UN – UNGA process

World Conference on Indigenous Peoples

Enabling the participation of indigenous governments at the UN